Wednesday, 14 April 2010

A man's a man for a' that

My favourite Flemish magazine has recently had a couple of articles that really annoyed me. One was a test asking "How masculine are you?" The other was an article entitled "Are men allowed to cry?" Allowed, for fuck's sake. That's enough to drive me up the wall. Their answer seemed to be that "Yes, some grown men do cry." Which absolutely made me drop my club and fall out of my tree. Really? Men sometimes cry? Bloody hell. It's like we've gone back to the 1950s or something.

The test which was meant to determine a man's manliness focused mainly on how much they know about sports (the more the better), how little they do around the house (less is more) and how bad they are at discussing their feelings (bad being good, of course). Now of course I know this test was all in jest, and mostly tongue-in-cheek, but it still bugged me. A lot. Most men I like and respect would have been classed in the "bottom" two categories, which could broadly be described as metrosexuals and nancy-boys. (It was a very subtle test, with subtle answers to match.) I shudder to even imagine being with a man who goes in the "top" two categories, which I would class as Neanderthal and macho man. (I can be subtle right back.)

Then tonight, discussing this with my metrosexual (according to the test) husband, we worked out the problem. The magazine writers were describing what makes a man "masculine," which is a matter of hair, sports and insensitivity. What I respect in a male of mine, though, is that he is "a man," which to me means that he's kind, responsible, a good husband and father, someone you can build on. After that, hairiness or interest in sports don't really register on the scale.

16 comments:

  1. oh yeah, god, at least when us women get the shits about body image or career pressure or flabby upper arms (random -ahem- example there) we're allowed (allowed!) to moan about it. imagine having all the same freak outs and not being 'allowed' to talk about it.

    when i was back in australia and had just met my future ex french husband i saw his flat for the first time and thought he was surely gay...all the nice decoration, the tasteful flowers...it totally confused me, i was completely programmed for hairy maleness. terrible.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Fairly typical economic crisis fodder - motherhood blazened around as true fulfilment for all (women), brutal images of masculinity retrieved from the archives...That'll solve the unemployment crisis then, won't it?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sounds like that quiz was written by hairy, stupid men who want smart women who are dating/married to smary, empathetic, loving men to feel like they're really with a closeted gay guy and that way the women will freak out and dump the metrosexual for the cave-dweller who hasn't had a decent relationship ever.

    Or does that just sound like some paranoid conspiracy theory?? :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. And there was me looking forward to a bit of Burns....

    Hairy, Scottish (I thought the two go hand in hand, but you may differ), cries occasionally, does his fair share of nappy changing, isn't allowed to watch sport because I find it boring, husband would doubtless agree...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nancy-boys. I am surrounded by them. Apparently the masculine genes passed every male I know.

    ReplyDelete
  6. My husband busts all the rules. He is definitely a man's man in that he does love sports (and played them) and he is happiest outside whether in the garden or in the woods BUT he cries easily, he cradles his grandson in his arms and kisses him with complete and utter enthusiasm and is tender when he needs to be.
    I am freaking lucky.
    But I would never, ever expect him to arrange flowers or be any damn good at picking out a tie.

    ReplyDelete
  7. What? Although I've only seen the hubby cry once or twice, he's not necessarily a neanderthal but rather a sensitive, caring, well-rounded human. Not to mention hot.

    I probably could have left the last part out huh?

    Hey, I got to wondering....Is the damn grocery store done with it's makeover yet?

    ReplyDelete
  8. I make the same distinction as you, only I call it "guys" vs "men". Guys are afraid of/oblivous to their feelings, guys cringe at 'women's hygiene' commercials on television (even when they live with real, live, menstruating women), guys live for sports and have the conversational ability of a park bench, and, should they ever deign to shove a broom about the house or look after their own children, are doing their wives a favour.

    Men, on the other hand, are aware of and will speak of their feelings, may well enjoy sports but are not monomaniacal about them, enjoy conversation (and not just about sports, their job and cars), see housework as necessary and childcare as something to be shared, and men will not only buy their wife's tampons, but probably remember the brand better than she does.

    It may even be that I am describing husband #1 and husband #2 here... You can decide which one's which. :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Well Duh. The only true test of masculinity is penis size. Jeez. Some people.

    ;)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Here here! My hubby is a man. He takes care of his family and lives up to his responsibilities. Sure, he likes a good hockey game, but he's just as happy to go pick up some tampons from the store for me. And he doesn't "babysit" his own children...he tells his mates he's giving his wife a well deserved break and taking his kids out for some fun.

    Stupid magazine quizzes.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Amen sister.
    I love your tag words!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Whenever my husband and I look at those kind of quizzes, it comes out that he's really the woman and I'm the man. You know that book "why women can't read maps and men aren't good listeners"? Well, guess what. I'm a great map reader (and he's hopeless), and he's a far more patient listener than I am.

    ReplyDelete
  13. What a horrible quiz!

    I have a big, hairy, (sweaty), masculine man who is also a big sensitive soul and nearly cried this morning because Kai didn't give him a kiss.

    The funny thing is that if all men WERE like the alpha-macho-dickhead category then the human race would have died out because they would make awful fathers and we would never have mated with them.

    ReplyDelete
  14. @screamish - Luckily we're enlightened women. :-)

    @Pueblo girl - Never thought of that. Quick sale stuff eh? Shame on them.

    @Geeks in Rome - I think that's probably a paranoid conspiracy theory, yes. :-)

    @planb - If it wasn't for husband changing nappies, I'd have given up on this baby thing long ago.

    @Angie - I like me a nancy-boy.

    @Ms. Moon - I don't think many people fit a category completely. And those that seem to often make me wonder. Babes doesn't really cry (I think it's the Scottish upbringing) but he's the sweetest father I've ever seen. And he's very good at tidying the house. (Which I'm TERRIBLE at.)
    I am freaking lucky, too.

    @Kingsmom - Ah, the shop. They seem to be done with the construction, but they are still moving the aisles about so I can never find anything. Less interesting pictorially, though.

    @MaryP - I sure hope you didn't downgrade to a Neanderthal. :-)

    @Cristin - We're okay then. :-)

    @Mad Woman - Men "babysitting" their own kids make me want to scream abuse and kick them.

    @Bethany - They're a nice way to say what I couldn't in the post itself.

    @Iota - I like to swear, my husband doesn't.

    @Josie - I don't know. The ape men I know seem to somehow manage to get themselves women they then use as their personal servants. Some of these women even seem to do this voluntarily.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I can't believe people are still writing these things in magazines. I agree with you 100%.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Dude by that definition I am a total man- I know alot about sports- do not so my share around the house and hate to discuss my feelings- I am not off to tell my husband that I am totally manly!

    ReplyDelete

Leave a comment, make my day!